That Girl (1966)

S3E3 Eleven Angry Men and That Girl

Ann takes her role in jury duty seriously and stands firm when the rest of the panel decides to vote "guilty" for a man charged with assaulting his wife with an ashtray. She presents her argument, noting that the accused wouldn’t have been able to strike her with his right hand, which sways the group. Ultimately, her reasoning leads them to change their minds and cast a vote for acquittal.